Verified answer

It really depends on your other players. If you have a weak 3B right now and a solid SS backup great trade. But if you already have a top of the line 3B or no one who is an adaqute SS replacement don't do it. All things being equal this is a bad trade. Reyes is the #1 player in the game and is one pace for 100 runs, 100 SB, and 100 RBIs. A-Rod since the first week in May has been slumping and has not been producing like in April.

No Reyes is better and has had a pretty good year even if Arsenal had a disappointing year. I can see why the trader would accept!

Chelsea are the best!!!

Keep Jose, he's been doing excellent the entire year with almost no slumps. Rodriguez did have that stretch where he wasn't so hot. It could almost go either way but I'd keep Jose.

No way. I have Reyes and he's done so good for me. If I were giving him away i'd get someone who could produce on a more consistent level than ARod

well if you need sb's and avg. then you should keep Reyes. If you need Home Runs and Rbi's then get A Rod. All up to you.

it depends who you have @ att 3rd && if you have a power hitter i myself would do the trade if you have another power hitter early in the season i traded away manny rameriez and the only power threat i had was Arod and i lost some gm's lol.!!

kinda think its dumb

reyes will ahve a better avg and more runs

all depends on what you need... but keep this in mind a-rod always chokes.... GO SOX

it's good for you.