I'm a Japanese student studying English.
Do the following sentences have the same meaning?
Linda had three times as many pens as I did.
Linda had three times more pens than I did.
I think the former means Linda had 30 pens if I had 10
and the latter, Linda had 40 if I had 10,
but a lot of native speakers say there's no difference,
Then how about the followings?
Linda had half as many pens as I did.
Linda had half more pens than I did.
In this case, I think the former means Linda had 5 pens if I had 10
and the latter means Linda had 15 if I had 10,
and this difference appears clearer than the upper one.
What do you native users of English think?
Copyright © 2024 Q2A.ES - All rights reserved.
Answers & Comments
Verified answer
Hi,
You can save yourself all the trouble of analyzing these differences. The fact is that all of your sentences that say *more* countable things are grammatically, or at least idiomatically, incorrect. The usage is this: For non-countable things such as cake, coke, food, etc. use "more than." For countable things such as books, pens, computers, etc. use "as many as."
Hope this helps.
FE