1. The problem statement, all variables and given/known data
Use partial differential calculus to show that if 3 quantities p, V, T are related to each other by some
unknown but smooth (which means all derivatives are well defined) equation of state f (P, V, T ) = 0. Then the
partial derivatives must satisfy the relation
∂p/∂T = - (∂V /∂T ) / ( (∂V /∂p) )
2. Relevant equations
Not sure any would help in this case.
3. The attempt at a solution
I'm not even sure where to start since I haven't a proper understanding of the problem.
If p, V, and T are related then
how does f (P, V, T ) = 0 help?
Copyright © 2024 Q2A.ES - All rights reserved.
Answers & Comments
Verified answer
This is a general properties of partial derivatives of functions of more than one variable; it's not just restricted to state functions.
Take any three variables that are related by some well-behaved function f(x,y,z) = 0. That means we can always rewrite this function as z = g(x,y), or y = h(x,z), or z = k(y,z), where g, h, and k are other well-behaved functions.
Let x be a function of y and z. Take the total differential of x:
dx = (∂x/∂y)_z dy + (∂x/∂z)_y dz
Take the total differential of y:
dy = (∂y/∂x)_z dx + (∂y/∂z)_x dz
Now substute the expression for dy in this last equation for dy in the first:
dx = (∂x/∂y)_z *[(∂y/∂x)_z dx + (∂y/∂z)_x dz] + (∂x/∂z)_y dz
dx = (∂x/∂y)_z * (∂y/∂x)_z dx + (∂x/∂y)_z * (∂y/∂z)_x dz + (∂x/∂z)_y dz
0 = [(∂x/∂y)_z * (∂y/∂x)_z - 1] dx + [(∂x/∂y)_z * (∂y/∂z)_x + (∂x/∂z)_y] dz
Because x and z are independent variables, and can be changed at will, both of the factors in brackets must independently be equal to zero in order for this equation to be true. This implies that:
(∂x/∂y)_z * (∂y/∂x)_z = 1
and
(∂x/∂y)_z * (∂y/∂z)_x + (∂x/∂z)_y = 0
-(∂x/∂y)_z * (∂y/∂z)_x = (∂x/∂z)_y
-(∂x/∂y)_z /(∂x/∂z)_y = 1/(∂y/∂z)_x
Using the previous result, we can also write this as:
-(∂x/∂y)_z /(∂x/∂z)_y = (∂z/∂y)_x
This is a general result. In your case, let x = V, y = T, and z = p, then:
-(∂V/∂T)_p /(∂V/∂p)_T = (∂p/∂T)_V
Which is what you are supposed to show.
PV = nRT P, T, n, R are given, discover V differentiate with appreciate to time t, be conscious that n and R are fixed P(dV/dt) + V(dP/dt) = nR (dT/dt) P, dP/dt, dT/dt, n and R are all given, and you merely got here upon V, discover dV/dt.