During Matam. Cutting with Zanjeer. What is your alliby, as WHAT is your reason as to cut your skin for Ali (r.a.), what is your reason to mutilate yourself? Please quote refrences from your holy scriptures as you have a seperate Hadith YOURSELF, and I am interested as to LEARN how the events of Karbala impact your lifestyle, and keep in mind, Im here to LEARN from you, not to insult. I love my Muslim Ummah. Salaam Waalaikom.
Update:look it up on either http://images.google.com/ yaaa Http://youtube.com
its brutal. i wonder what could be the reason as to why those who take PART in this..tradition, would do it. What is the justification?
Copyright © 2024 Q2A.ES - All rights reserved.
Answers & Comments
Verified answer
Battle of Uhud
Muhammad had only been wounded
due to missiles of stone which resulted in a gash on his forehead and lip.result a broken teeth
I heart there was a sahabi who heart that and he also break his a couple of teeth with a stone after that Prophet said to that man that he will have a home in heavens . so . . . .
If we cut our self a bit and tell the ummah that if we were there we would behead yazeed (LA)
what's wrong with that
The events of Karbala inspire us to become better Muslims, because all those people who were slaughtered in those battles were slaughtered defending Islam.
However, there is absolutely no justification for the self-mutilation, and I am horrified that people still do things like this in the twenty-first century. I thought it was haraam to harm yourself? That's why drugs are haraam, that's why alcohol is haraam. You're by no means allowed to cut your head open or beat yourself with metal spikes. It's despicable and hypocritical!
I respect you for asking in true curiosity, and I thank you. The majority of the people who ask this question nowadays are just asking it to make Shi'as look bad.
The shiaeh do it to to suffer and show how sad are they for Ali<r .a> death and all of this is haram you are now own your body to do this to it Allah made it not you to cut skin and i saw some people hit them self is sword to show the suffer and the sadness of Ali <r.a> death and this is haram
and Mohammad <saw> said <in badanak 3alaik 7ak>
etky Allah fe nafsek
umm, ya, i didn't read your question, at all... but your display picture looks very peaceful to our Muslim Ummah.
thanks for contributing!
wow, never heard of that. but i'm sunni.