I have no idea who to start and have talked myself into and out of starting every single player on my roster. Maybe someone can help me think clearly again. Here's what I've got:

QB Peyton Manning at Ari

WR Randy Moss vs Atl

WR Steve Smith (NYG) at TB

WR Mario Manningham at TB

RB Ryan Grant at StL

RB Darren Sproles vs Mia

TE Jeremy Shockey at Buf

W/R/T Tim Hightower vs Ind

BN Leon Washington vs Ten

BN Santana Moss at Det

BN Bernard Berrian vs SF

BN Patrick Crayton vs Car

BN LeSean McCoy vs KC

BN Brett Favre vs SF

BN Bo Scaife at NYJ

BN Kevin Boss at TB

What I'm thinking: I don't like the idea of starting 2 WR from the Giants, but those two guys have been the most consistent for me. S. Moss did absolutely nothing against the worst pass defense in the league, so I'm very nervous about starting him. I've considered starting Crayton because Car isn't the best on defense, but I don't know if I should take out Manningham or Smith if I do start Crayton. Then, if Moss does not play on Sunday, who should I put in to replace him??? I think Hightower will have a good game against a nonexistant Colts run defense, but L. Washington will get me return yards in addition to what he does on offense. And by the way, this is NOT a PPR league. All in all, I'm very confused and any help would be appreciated!