Verified answer

If you can afford to give up the saves (and it seems you can), then it's a pretty good deal for you. Beltran and Reyes (plus whichever OF you find on waivers or have on your bench) will give you an increase in both HR and SB over the Hardy/Ichiro/Sizemore. And I'm a big fan of selling high on Vogelsong... he's never done anything like this in his career, and I expect a second-half decline from him. Feliz + Vogelsong for Gallardo is a fair give up to improve your offense.

The biggest question I had as well was giving up the saves, but if you have three solid closers already then I say do it and get out of Sizemore and Vogelsong before they lose value.

depending on what you have available on the waiver wire to pick up for the 2 spots you will open up i would say as is pretty even reyes is the best but hardy is doing well now but who knows if he can keep it up so reyes wins there beltran is doing good so basically you are getting him for sizemore and ichiro which is even trade felix and vogelsong for galloardo is the hard part? even trade if you can give up the saves. this is where the waiver wire comes in if you can pick up a closer on the wire then yes do the trade without thinking about it otherwise its still a good trade if you can afford to give up the saves good luck

You're getting the better players, but overpaying.

you win that trade